Eurozone crisis live: China tells Europe to 'do its homework' - 2 February 2012

Angela Merkel and Wen Jiabao at an official welcoming ceremony in Beijing.
Angela Merkel and Wen Jiabao at an official welcoming ceremony in Beijing today. Photograph: David Gray/Reuters

5.09pm: European markets have closed and the FTSE 100 has edged up to a new six month high. And I mean edged. The index has finished 5.35 points higher at 5796.07, boosted by news of the proposed €82bn merger between commodities groups Glencore and Xstrata.

As befits Groundhog day, the soundbites about the Greek debt situation were reassuringly familiar, with hopes of a resolution by the end of the week, or by Monday's EU finance ministers meeting perhaps.

Angela Merkel's visit to China saw more vague hints of help from that quarter to resolve the eurozone crisis. And with the ECB's liquidity programme continued to help bond auctions get away successfully, German, French and Italian markets all edged higher.

Tomorrow sees the US non-farm payroll figures, while we can also expect more on Greece and the rest of the eurozone ahead of the weekend and Monday's meeting.

And with that we'll close up for the evening. Thanks as usual for all the comments, and see you tomorrow.

4.31pm: More on Greece. The country's finance minister Evangelos Venizelos has said talks have begun about boosting the size of the country's €130bn bailout.

It appears it could be boosted by another €15bn. Meanwhile Venizelos said the terms of public sector participation in the proposed debt swap had yet to be resolved.

However German finance minister Wolfgang Schaeuble said in an interview on German television that Greece's public sector creditors had already done enough, and an additional contribution was not required. This presumably refers to the ECB.

Agreement? What agreement?

Schaeuble was also quoted as saying he hoped there would still be 17 eurozone members at the end of 2012. We shall see.

3.53pm: A transport strike in Portugal today seems to have failed to make much of an impact.

In contrast to the protests in Greece about the austerity measures the country's beleagured government is trying to impose, the Portuguese are so far taking things a bit more calmly. According to Reuters, trains and buses were running and only Lisbon's metro and the ferries shut down:

"We are analysing why (train and bus) workers didn't mobilize as we had expected," said Jose Manuel Oliveira, a coordinator for the FETRANS transport union.

I'll bet.

 Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke delivers the Fed's monetary policy report. Photograph: Dennis Cook/AP

Ben Bernanke, the chairman of the US Federal Reserve, has told Congress there were signs the uncertainty dogging the American economy was easing, but the eurozone crisis still threatened the country's recovery. He said in his prepared testimony:

Risks remain that developments in Europe or elsewhere may unfold unfavourably and could worsen economic prospects here at home.

He believed the US housing market was still depressed and tight credit conditions could weigh on consumer spending. Ahead of tomorrow's non-farm payrolls he said there were signs of modest improvement in the labour market but the pace of recovery was extremely slow.

And he said a top priority should be to change US fiscal policy and described the current debt levels as "unsustainable."

The Fed is widely expected to embark on another round of quantitative easing in the coming months to help spur the economy.

3.09pm: Jean-Claude Juncker, the head of the Eurogroup of finance ministers, is not the only negative voice on the continuing crisis.

As we reported earlier, he told German radio the Private Sector Involvement talks in Greece are "ultra-difficult". He was also critical of the progress made at Monday's summit, saying the measures agreed were "largely insufficient."

This has been echoed by the OECD, which has said the EFSF and ESM bailout funds need to have their resources doubled to €1trn.

Without the firewall being strengthened in this way, the eurozone was exposed to the risk of fracturing. Writing in a research report OECD special advisor Adrian Blundell-Wignall, said private investors were unlikely to put up the necessary funds. One option to resolve this would be to give the EFSF a banking licence so it could borrow from the European Central Bank.

How would that go down with Angela Merkel? And what would we call such an entity - the Bailout Bank? Bank of Bust Countries?

Meanwhile we have another EU meeting to look forward to on Monday. According to Reuters:

Euro zone finance ministers aim to agree a second financing package for Greece on Monday, a decision they hope will boost market confidence in euro zone public finances and help contain the two-year-old sovereign debt crisis.
A deal for Greece would include agreement on official new financing, the size of voluntary losses banks and other private bondholders are willing to accept and new reforms Athens must undertake.

Henry McDonald

2.55pm: Back with the eurozone, there are some discouraging comments on the outlook for the Republic of Ireland from its central bank, which said the country would remain in recession this year.

In its latest survey of the Irish economy, the bank downgraded the
country's growth projections for 2012. Here's Henry McDonald with the details:

The Central Bank said Irish Gross National Product would shrink by 0.7% - mainly due to a drop in the export market.

But the main weakness in the economy remains domestic demand with GDP
only growing by 0.5 per cent and not 1.8% as the bank previously projected.

However, it says that Gross Domestic Product growth, which includes multinationals, will grow by 0.5%, not 1.8% as previously predicted.

While Irish exports peformed strongly in 2011 the Central Bank said the drop in global demand particularly in the eurozne would see a reduction in export led growth.

However the Central Bank also predicted a pick-up in export growth in 2013 but only if the projected recovery in world demand in the second half of 2012.

It also said that exports will continue to contribute positively to overall GDP growth, which will offset the continued slowing of domestic demand.

Despite the significant reduction to growth forecasts, the Central Bank said the Irish Government will hit its 8.6% target of deficit of GDP in line with the bail out deal Ireland received from the ECB and IMF.

2.50pm: Ahead of a testimony shortly by US Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke in front of the House budget committee, the Dow Jones Industrial Average has dipped around 10 points in early trading.

This despite a dip in US weekly jobless claims by 12,000 to 367,000, which is encouraging ahead of tomorrow's non-farm payroll numbers. Economists are expecting these to show a 135,000 to 150,000 rise in employment after a 200,000 jobs were created last month, much better than forecast.

Live blog: substitution

2.22pm: The latest Spanish employment data showed that its jobless crisis is accelerating.

Spain's government reported that less than 8% of all new job contracts signed in January were permanent, suggesting that firms are relying on temporary workers - who are much easier to lay off.

Today's data showed that the number of people signing on unemployment benefit jumped 4% in January. Engracia Hidalgo, deputy labor minister, said the figures were:

evidence of the country's deep economic crisis.

With that, I'm signing off to let Nick Fletcher carry on. Thanks all.

2.02pm: What if that groundhog did economic forecasts, rather than the weather?…

(oh, and Puxatawny Phil predicts six more weeks of winter).

1.48pm: The latest weekly jobless data from the US showed a drop in the number of people signing on, to 367,000. That should fuel optimism that America's labour market is recovering.

1.28pm: Losing its AAA rating with S&P doesn't seem to have casued France many problems. In fact, its 10-year bonds have strengthened to their highest value since December, pushing the yield on the securities below the 3% mark.

France also had a good result in the bond market, selling €7.96bn bonds at lower yields. Another triumph for the liquidity rally.

1.11pm: Peter Goves of Citi suggests that today's Spanish €4.5bn bond auction wasn't quite as successful as I suggested.

Goves points out that, while Spain's borrowing costs fell, it didn't repeat its recent achievement of selling much more debt than planned. He writes:

Live blog - France flag

On 12th Jan, Spain sold nearly €10bn vs a target range of €4bn- €5bn across the 3yr-5yr sectors, and on 19th Jan, Spain sold €6.6bn vs a target range of €3.5bn-€4.5bn.

The fact that Spain has issued more than the target range at recent auctions has been a distinguishing feature of the sovereign's issuance programme. Therefore going forward, this will likely continue to be another metric in gauging auction success.

As if Madrid didn't have enough problems…

12.43pm: Megan Greene, senior economist at Roubini Global Economics, has predicted today that Italy will be forced to restructure its debts.

Italian 10-year bond yields are back around 5.7% today, some distance from their recent highs, but Greene argues that this is a temporary relief.

Writing on Italian news site Linkiesta.it this afternoon, she argues that Mario Monti will fail to reform the Italian economy before financial markets lose faith in the country, pushing bond yields up to unsustainable levels. At that stage it would take a bailout from Europe (through the European Stability Mechanism) -- but Italy's huge borrowing needs mean the ESM would run dry before Monti's task was complete.

That would leave Italy, and its creditors, facing a painful debt restructuring in two or three years time.

From the article:


The easing of bond yields in the early weeks of 2012 has lifted some of the pressure on EU leaders to find an immediate resolution to the eurozone crisis.

But the fundamentals have not changed.

It is only a matter of time before Italy's economic performance causes investors to question the country's solvency once again. The only way to ensure Italy's future in the eurozone is for Italy to return to growth, but it is unlikely that EU leaders will be able to buy enough time for this to happen.

12.10pm: The euro has just dropped below the $1.31 mark as comments from Jean-Claude Juncker, who heads up the Eurogroup of finance ministers, hit the wires.

Juncker told German radio station Deutchslandfunk that the Private Sector Involvement talks in Greece are "ultra-difficult". That's not the word of a man who thinks a deal is close …

He was also critical of the progress made at Monday's summit, saying the measures agreed were "largely insufficient."

11.51am: Here's the key quote from Wen Jiabao, from his meeting with Angela Merkel (via Reuters' Beijing desk):

China is also considering increasing its participation in the solution of the European debt crisis through the channels of the EFSF and ESM.

Live blog - euro

The European Stability Mechanism is due to come into effect in July, superseding the European Financial Stability Fund (which has been financing Ireland, Greece and Portugal). As things stand, the ESM is pegged at €500bn – many key players (Christine Lagarde, Mario Monti …) have called for more resources, but Germany has been reluctant.

11.42am: Kevin Dunning of The Economist Intelligence Unit isn't surprised that Wen Jiabao didn't announce any new financial support for Europe.

He believes Angela Merkel will struggle to persuade China that there is '"no existential crisis" in Europe, just a debt and competitiveness crisis:


Although China certainly has huge foreign-currency reserves, it is likely to remain reserved about deploying them while the perception continues that the Europeans (who are considerably richer than the Chinese) are themselves not willing to put up the necessary funds to preserve their currency union.

China does already hold plenty of euro-denominated securities (around a quarter of its $3.2 trillion asset pile), making further eurozone debt less attractive. There's an argument that Beijing will be much more interested in buying up actual physical assets in Europe.

11.21am: Chinese premier Wen Jiabao says it is "very important" to resolve the eurozone debt crisis, and hinted that China might provide financial support.

Speaking with Angela Merkel in Beijing, Wen said he backed Europe's efforts to stabilise the euro. However he stopped short of announcing any new financial commitment - saying only that China was studying how it might help.

Wen also reiterated that Europe must help itself though its crisis, by cutting its debt load and introducing structural reforms.

Merkel also told journalists in Beijing that China had given her a message that Europe must "do its homework" on the crisis before getting help from elsewhere.

10.54am: Meanwhile, our correspondent in Athens, Helena Smith, says Greece's political leaders have confirmed that wage cuts remain the biggest "stumbling block" to an agreement over the country's next rescue package.

Angela Merkel attends an official welcoming ceremony with Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao. Angela Merkel attending an official welcoming ceremony with Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao. Photograph: David Gray/Reuters

Speaking to Flash radio this morning Giorgos Karatzaferis who leads LAOS, one of the three parties backing prime minister Lucas Papademos's interim government, highlighted what is at stake.

Even at the last minute our hope is that Greece will be saved from bankruptcy. Right now [negotiations are focusing] on the 13th and 14th wage.

That's a reference to the bonuses that are granted to workers in the private sector. Karatzaferis claimed that the money was vital to keep the Greek economy moving:

We are trying to save them so that Greeks can go out and buy a shirt or small present at Easter and summer … but Poul Thomsen [IMF mission chief] has become very hard, he is negotiating very hard.

Karatzaferis argued (perhaps a little optimistically) that Greeks could boost their competitiveness by working just a little harder:

Even Uganda … Albania, Skopje [the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia] are more competitive than us. But what I have argued is that if Greeks work longer, say an hour more a day … we can make the country more competitive without having to lose everything.

Karatzaferis also blamed the tortuously slow progress of open warfare in the socialist party, Pasok. Since stepping aside to make way for Papademos in November, former PM George Papandreou has faced many calls to quit the party leadership.

There is speculation that Papandreou may even be ousted at a crucial Pasok parliamentary group meeting this afternoon. Watch this space!

10.42am: Louise Cooper of BGC also reckoned that the European Central Bank will be overwhelmed with bids for cheap loans in a couple of weeks.

The ECB is due to hold its next Long Term Refinancing Operation later this month. At December's operation, European banks stunned the City by taking €489bn of low-cost, three-year loans (sparking the liquidity rally mentioned in the last post).

This time around, though, the chatter on the BGC trading desks is that banks could take €1.2tn.

Louise cites three reasons:
1) December's operation clashed with banks balancing their books for the end of the year, so some were reluctant to get heavily involved
2) The ECB has relaxed its rules on what assets it will accept as collateral.
3) There's no stigma in taking the money.

The fear, though, is that the ECB will actually panic the financial sector by handing out too many loans - making investors worry that the situation is even worse than they thought.

One thing's clear, though, as Louise says:

More cheap loans only put off the inevitable.

10.22am: Louise Cooper of BGC Partners confirms that today's successful Spanish bond auction (see 9.58am) is due to the €500bn of cheap three-year loans pumped into the European financial system by the ECB.

As she put it:

It's a liquidity rally, everything is rallying.

She also pointed out that Spanish banks have probably bought most of the bonds sold this morning, under pressure from the Madrid government. Those bonds could soon find their way back onto the secondary market - or stashed with the European Central Bank as liquidity.

Louise Cooper

The problem with liquidity rallies, of course, is that they don't do much to fix the underlying solvency problems faced by weaker eurozone countries. Spain's biggest problem is its huge unemployment rate and slow-growing economy – PM Rajoy hopes to use this window of opportunity to push economic reforms in, and also to persuade Europe to give him more time (by easing his deficit reduction targets).

9.58am: Looks like it's Groundhog Day in the bond markets too, where Spain just sold €4.5bn of debt at much lower costs than previously.

Investors bought three-year bonds at a yield of 2.8% (down from 3.38% paid just three weeks ago), while a five-year bond sold at a yield of 3.5% (from 5.5% in early January).

It's a familiar tale - auctions have been going well since the European Central Bank offered almost €500bn in cheap loans in late December.

Just getting some City reaction now... #ringring.

9.37am: UK construction data is out, and it shows that the sector kept growing in January - but at a slower pace. Markit's monthly survey of managers at building firms came in at 51.4 - its weakest result in four months, closer to the 50-point mark that marks stagnation.

Markit said the data should raise hopes that Britain can avoid a second quarter of negative growth. Yesterday, though, the Institute for Fiscal Studies reckoned a second recession was likely.

UPDATE: Andrew Duncan of programme management and construction consultancy Turner & Townsend says the construction data is unimpressive:

UK construction PMI, January 2012. UK construction PMI, January 2012. Photograph: Markit

January is traditionally is an upbeat month for the construction sector - as companies looking to expand begin putting wheels in motion....such a modest rise in construction output looks more than a little disappointing.

9.26am: Deutsche Bank, Germany's largest bank, has plunged into the red after running up heavy losses on its investment banking arm.

The eurozone crisis hit Deutsche Bank hard -- it took a writedown on its Greek government bonds, and reported weak trading activity as clients delayed deals and kept out of the financial markets.

Deutsche posted a pretax loss of €351m for the last quarter. Dirk Becker, analyst at stock broker Kepler, said the results were a "catastrophe."

Chief executive officer Josef Ackermann is briefing the media now. He attempted to calm nerves in Germany by saying Deutsche had increased its domestic lending by around 7% since the crisis began, but also warned of a threat of "deep recession" in the eurozone's weaker states.

9.00am: A spokesman for the Greek government said this morning that negotiations with its lenders are now focused on three issues - wages, pensions and bank recapitalision.

Pantelis Kapsis told Greek MEGA television that there are just a few "sticking points" to be cleared up before the Private Sector Involvement is cleared up.

Kapsis said:

On the one side, there is pressure to restore the economy's competitiveness fast. We are saying that there is clearly an issue of competitiveness.

On the other hand, there is also the question of recession which is very important for Greece.

The wage question focuses on Greece's minimum salary of €750 per month, which the IMF argue is too high. Union officials oppose the suggestion, saying a cut would drive more people into poverty and further damage consumer spending (retail sales are already sliding).

Live blog - Greece flag

8.29am: Angela Merkel's visit to Beijing isn't just about diplomacy, it's also about business.

The German chancellor is expected to meet with Chinese investors during her visit to Beijing, and officials are hoping that she might persuade them to invest in Europe.

German news magazine Spiegel reports:

A senior government representative stressed in Berlin on Tuesday that "Chinese investments are expressly welcome. They will be sought, used and appreciated" -- both in Germany and in the rest of the eurozone.

It may not be an easy sell. Three months ago, Klaus Regling of the EFSF toured the Far East looking for support, and came away empty handed.

8.17am: Angela Merkel began her visit to Beijing today by insisting that the single currency had made Europe stronger.

In a speech to the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, the German chancellor declared:

The euro has made Europe stronger.

She adding that EU members were "deeply" committed to the fiscal compact agreed at Monday's summit in Brussels, saying budget limits would prevent countries overspending in the future.

It will be interesting to see how Chinese media cover the visit, as Beijing officials have sometimes appeared unsympathetic to Europe.

Angela Merkel delivers a speech at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences in Beijing. Photograph: Carlos Barria/Reuters

As Jin Liqun, who chairs China's $400 billion sovereign wealth fund, stated last November: "[Europe's] labour laws induce sloth, indolence, rather than hardworking. The incentive system, is totally out of whack…"

7.55am: Appropriately enough, today is Groundhog Day in America -- the day when (folk wisdom states) the appearance of a small rodent out of its burrow will show whether sunny or cloudy weather is due.

Thanks to Hollywood, GroundHog Day is also associated with living the same events over and over (and over) again. That pretty much sums up the eurozone crisis in recent days, as the Greek debt restructuring talks have dragged on - punctuated by one side or the other claiming that a deal was close.

As Michael Hewson of CMC Markets put it this morning:

Given that it's Groundhog Day today its particularly apt that Greece continues to be the centre of continued speculation about what's happening with respect to the debt talks and the latest bailout.

Even so markets are now so bored with it, any comments by EU officials are now being dismissed with a perfunctory shrug and an "I'll believe it when I see it" attitude.

The latest official comment came from the Institute of International Finance (representing Greek bond holders) last night. It said that "constructive discussions" were continuing, and was hopeful of agreeing a deal "in the days ahead"....

Mike van Dulken, City trader at Accendo Markets, is also running low on patience, wondering which weekend the negotiators are aiming to finish by.

7.54am: Here's today's agenda, including some economic UK and European economic data:

• UK construction PMI data for January - 9.30am GMT
ª Eurozone producer price index for December - 10am GMT / 11am CET
ª US weekly jobless data - 1.30pm GMT / 8.30am EST
• Ben Bernanke testifies before the House Budget panel - 3pm GMT / 10am EST

Bond auctions:
• France to sell €6.5bn-€8bn of long-term debt
• Spain to sell €3.5bn-€4.5bn of various bonds

+ Angela Merkel in China until Friday

7.45am: Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the eurozone financial crisis.

Live blog: recap

On the menu today: Angela Merkel is visiting China for top-level meetings with premier Wen Jiabao and president Hu Jintao. Europe's fiscal plans will be discussed, along with China's policy on the yuan.

Merkel's visit will be closely watched for signs that China might be prepared to offer support to help Europe through the debt crisis, and for her own views on the situation.

Elsewhere, the protracted negotiations between Greece and her creditors are continuing. Those involved still claim that an agreement could be close, but City analysts are openly sceptical about these pronouncements.

In the bond markets, Spain and France will auction sovereign debt this morning.

And Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke is due to appear on Capitol Hill to answer questions from the House Budget Committee.

We have switched off comments on this old version of the site. To comment on crosswords, please switch over to the new version to comment. Read more...

On our daily blog we report on the turmoil in the bond, stock and currency markets - as well as the political dramas at the heart of the eurozone crisis.